Busted Halo

Paulist seminarian Tom Gibbons reflects on his formation experience and his life as a seminarian right now. Along the way, some questions will be will be answered, and a lot more will come up.

Click this banner to see the entire section.

November 9th, 2009



36674004_CROPI have never technically been a New Yorker.  Even though my parents both grew up in Brooklyn and I grew up in Northern New Jersey—the half of the Garden State that roots for the Yankees and knew Al Roker long before he moved downstairs to the Today Show—full membership into the Big Apple was always for me a distant beacon that loomed past the horizon… much like Karl Rahner’s description of the experience of God.  For me, it was not until I would be required to memorize subway routes in order to plan a regular morning commute could ever I hope to become a part of the club that understood Seinfeld on a deeper level.

But on a sunny morning this past May, I woke up to car horns and the magical smells of the breakfast cart five stories below… yes, I find ham and egg sandwiches magical.  Later in the day I asked three different guys which place in the neighborhood had the best thin-crust pizza… and got five different answers.  On the way to suggestion number four, I passed by a bar in which the Yankees were playing.  Do you have any idea how long it has been since I have lived in a city that roots for the Yankees?  Answer: too long. And all of this “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah” was happening in my new mid-town Manhattan address: St. Paul the Apostle.

At this writing, I am at the halfway point of my formation towards priesthood: three down, three to go.  In the previous three years with the Paulists I have shopped in independent record stores in Berkeley, crossed the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco, eaten gelato in front of the Pantheon in Rome, and visited Graceland.  In between these adventures I have been praying, studying, and discerning what the life of a priest might mean for me.  And the last two words of the previous sentence were added intentionally: “for me.

There has been a charmed aspect of “unreality” in my formation thus far; an unreality I have certainly enjoyed but on some gut level know is not a basis on which to build a life of ministry.  I am also aware that I am ready to start having this new life be about others in addition to what adventures I have been fortunate to have along the way.  In my chaplaincy program at the hospital this past summer, the formation experience moved from an “unreality” to a “hyper-reality,” trading in theology books for patient’s charts.  But I also believe that this new “hyper-reality” is closer to what the priesthood is supposed to be about.

I make few apologies for maintaining an inward focus during the first three years of seminary, if for not other reason that I want to have myself sorted out within this new life before what is inside me is offered as harbor for others… as much as possible, anyway.  Throughout that time, I did a lot of writing about the experience, and so this blog will detail some of the online journal entries I have made over the past few years as well us updates from the present day.  Looking back over some of those older entries, some of the questions that were raised have been addressed, others have been answered, and a lot more questions have made their appearance.  But if I am now at the halftime show of my formation, these older journal entries describe where I was just after the coin-flip that determined  the side of the field I would receive kick-off three years ago: Catholic priesthood.

The Author : Fr. Tom Gibbons
Since 2009, Tom Gibbons, CSP, has shared insights on faith, pop culture, and seminary life in the Kicking and Screaming blog here at Busted Halo. On May 19, 2012, Tom was ordained a Paulist priest at St. Paul the Apostle Church in New York City. He will begin serving St. Peter's Catholic Church in Toronto, Canada beginning in July 2012.
See more articles by (98).
Please note that the editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness.
  • gus

    Tom, Sounds like you’d be a good recruiter for the priesthood in generalIn the hussle and bussel of your ministry don’t forget to stop and smell the flowers (spiritual reading and quiet times with the Lord)

  • Tom Gibbons

    Thanks for the comments everyone! It’s always great to hear about people’s experiences with the Paulists. As the blog unfolds I’ll be talking more about why priesthood and why the Paulists, as well as including some of my homilies and stories that are going on with me now.

  • Audrey

    Dear Tom, I was introduced to the Paulist Fathers when I was a little girl through a television program the order produced called “Insight.” I was very young but the show has really stuck with me all these many years (I am 44 now!). Somehow even then I knew the Paulists were special! Thank you for your glimpse of life as a seminarian. I am praying for you as you continue your journey to the priesthood. May God Bless You. Audrey

  • Max Lindenman

    Well, Tom, I’m thrilled to see you’ve carried the ball past the fifty-yard line. I hope you’ll let us in on some of the backstory — namely, why the priesthood, and why the Paulists?

    It’s great you were able to devote such a good-sized chunk of time to reflection and discernment.

    Just recently, I started reading about your founder, Isaac Hecker. If I’m remmbering this correctly, he entered the priesthood at a time when Americans had formed a political party for the sole purpose of shutting Catholic immigrants out of America, and when Philadelphians were literally up in arms to prevent Catholic children from studying the Douay-Rheims Bible in public schools. Fr. Hecker’s reaction — “Great! Time to start converting people!” — testfies to the quality of his vision, not to mention the quality of his moxie. I have no doubt you’ll do him proud.

    Best of luck, and keep writing.

  • Christy

    I’m excited to hear about your journey. Our small town parish was recently blessed with the presence of a seminarian embarking on his first year of pastoral care practicum. He got very involved, and was more than willing to share his story of faith. Which I think is more of what is needed if we want young men and women to see that the clergy are normal people too:) Blessings on your journey :)

  • mags

    Tom – it will be interesting to see your journey unfold. many seminarians I have spoken to have seen their first years as a place of safety – a three year retreat. But Jesus sends us all ‘out’.I’m sure this will be an exciting and compelling time of growth. Thanks for sharing and God Bless the journey.

powered by the Paulists