Busted Halo
feature: entertainment & lifestyle
October 17th, 2012

Recipes and Rites: Finding Grace in a Polish Kitchen


Whiting, Indiana's annual Pierogi Festival (CNS photo by Karen Callaway, Northwest Indiana Catholic)

It was 5 o’clock in the afternoon, and I had spent the last seven hours with three older ladies: Marilyn, Kathy and Irene, who descended from the Irish, Slovak and Polish people respectively. I was learning to make pierogi, which, for the uninitiated, is a Slavic sort of ravioli. At the soup kitchen where I have worked for almost a year, my supervisor Monsignor Joseph Kelly had sent me to his older sister Marilyn that I might learn to cook from her Polish friend, Irene. “Be sure,” he added, “to ask Irene about the trip she took to Ireland.”

“They were all Irish like Marilyn,” Irene said, laughing, “I was the only Polish girl on that whole trip, and I was the only one to bend over backwards and kiss the Blarney Stone. That was when my back was still good.” Now her back is bent with scoliosis, and although she has a fancy remote-controlled gadget implanted above her hip, she spent most of the time directing the operations of the kitchen from her seat, rising only once when I had fabulously ruined the first batch of dough and the crisis necessitated experienced fingers to patch it up with an appropriate amount of sour cream.

While my own grandmother was Polish (her maiden name was Szmanda, which, Irene told me, is pronounced Schmanda), I had never heard of pierogi until I came to Scranton, a city in northeastern Pennsylvania that sits atop a honeycomb of anthracite mines. The city has magnificent Catholic churches every few blocks, one for each brand of European immigrant who, like Irene’s father, came to work in the coal industry a mile and more beneath our feet. The flavors of those immigrants still perfume the valley.

Rolling dough

The ladies and I made almost 100 pierogi. I learned common tips (mound the sauerkraut and cabbage filling, but make the potato and cheese into more of a log) and old secrets. I rolled dough, and rolled dough, and rolled more dough, until my forearms were tired. From her seat, calmly filling the pierogi shells, Irene assured me that the dough would get better each time I made it. And, true to her prophecy, after I rolled out the third and final batch, Irene patted the dough with her hand and said, “Oh this is perfect,” and she said it with such gentleness, such sincerity, that I felt seven-eighths Szmanda pronounced Schmanda rather than only one-eighth, and I would have happily rolled such perfect dough from that summer afternoon until the next Wigilia.

Irene patted the dough with her hand and said, “Oh this is perfect,” and she said it with such gentleness, such sincerity, that I felt seven-eighths Szmanda pronounced Schmanda rather than only one-eighth, and I would have happily rolled such perfect dough from that summer afternoon until the next Wigilia.

Irene made me roll the entire third batch of dough for pierogi, even the last pebble that I could not imagine would hold any filling (although she made it work). But the scraps of the first two batches I pushed together, rolled out across the table, and cut with a knife into thin shoelaces in order to make a noodle which Irene and Kathy called haluski. At first I was being meticulous to cut each strip the same length, but Irene and Kathy rushed me. Irene was flouring the strips, and throwing them up and down to keep them from sticking to one another, while Kathy dropped them into the boiling water. “I have to put them in at the same time, so work faster and stop worrying,” Kathy said. “This isn’t pierogi, this is haluski, and it’s not supposed to be perfect.”

“He came to us as food”

The heyday of the coal mine and its laborers and the churches they built in eastern Pennsylvania was all a long time ago, and now most of the mines and many of the churches have been abandoned. But, as I said, the food remains: each summer the cash-strapped churches have festivals, and beside the hamburgers and gravy fries and Texas wieners, the Polish churches will sell their pierogi, the Italians their pizza, and the Irish their potato pancakes. And now at the Nativity church festival, where I first tried a pierogi, they also have a booth where parishioners sell tacos in homemade tortillas and Brazilian tapas.

“It’s earthy stuff,” a priest told me once. We weren’t talking about pierogi, but we might have been. “You have to thirst, you have to hunger. Because He came to us as food, and I think that’s an important mystery.”

I pressed him, saying, “What if I’m sitting in a pew thinking about work, distracted? I’m not particularly hungering for the Eucharist, should I go up to receive?”

“Absolutely,” he said, “because that’s a different question. Now it’s a question of grace. And you never deserve the Eucharist. You go as you are, and not as you think you should be.”

In other words: It is food, and it nourishes us, and that is a mystery, but it’s blue-collar food, the stuff of miners and migrant workers. It’s flour and water, same as pierogi and haluski, or ravioli, or tortillas.

We come to receive the Eucharist carrying everything to the table, all that we mixed in with the extra spoonful of sour cream: the broken backs and the old black lungs, the trying, the forgetting and feeling again the words of our husband, our mother, our siblings alive or long dead. It’s the growing up and falling apart, remembering who we used to be and discovering — all over, or for the first time — who we are.

The post was originally published on August 20, 2012.

The Author : Seth Einterz
Seth Einterz grew up outside of Indianapolis, where he attended St. Monica's Parish. He ran cross country at Wabash College, where he majored in philosophy. In August, after finishing his year at St. Francis of Assisi Kitchen in Scranton, Pennsylvania, he will matriculate as a student of Georgetown Medical School. 
See more articles by (2).
Please note that the editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness.
  • Ginny Kubitz Moyer

    Thanks for this great article! I’ll be passing it around among the members of my Polish-American family. We have an annual Polish dinner where we eat crazy amounts of pierogi … I could practically taste it, reading your article. And I love how you connect it to the Eucharist. Thanks again.

  • John Kennedy

    Seth, we miss you already at the kitchen. Such a great article above. Hope all is well…

  • Stephanie

    Such a good piece! The reflection on the Eucharist reminds me of a quote I just read from C.S. Song, an Asian theologian: “There is such a thing as a theology with a mouth–not so much in the sense of a theology that speaks profound things as in the sense of a theology that eats the food set before it. Theology…cannot be choosy about what it eats. Wherever it goes, it must be able to digest the food provided by the given locality.”

  • J

    Still and still moving.

  • Nancy Gilmer Stone

    Great piece—and then I see you are one of “our own”—a St. Monica parishioner! I know your parents, of course and will share your wonderful article with friends and family in Indy, especially a Polish-American friend who grew up on pierogis!

powered by the Paulists