Busted Halo
feature: politics & culture
November 12th, 2008

The Obama Gap

A boomer contemplates the millenials on the night of the election


Nov. 4, 2008 — I’m hanging out in an enormous public room at Chestnut Hill College in Philadelphia. A large screen TV has one election coverage team chattering and there is an even larger screen on which is projected another channel’s chatterers. We flip from channel to channel (Fox News eliciting boos and laughs), while the screens flip between the talking heads and brightly colored maps of the U.S.A. The states are slowly filling, red and blue and more blue.

Dozens of students, black and white and Latino and Asian, lounge on couches or chat with friends. They type on laptops and click and text. Many have one ear bud from an iPod in one ear; the other ear is “open” for the outside world. This is their multi-media, multi-racial environment, constant lights and noises, constant interaction among various groups, as familiar to them as various waters to fish. At 11 p.m. EST, one of the talking heads sonorously announces Barack Obama has won the election. The room erupts in gentle and heartfelt whoops and hollers. There is a subtle euphoria in the air, but one notes also the overriding coolness that hallmarks this generation. They give their hearts, but gingerly and gently. To be honest, there was a lot more noise and wild celebration when the Phillies won the World Series the week before than when Obama gained the White House.

Nov. 5, 2008 — I am standing in front of my anthropology class. At the end of the 75 minutes, we take some time to reflect on the previous day’s election. Students are mostly quietly elated and excited about Obama; a smattering grudgingly let go of their McCain-Palin connection. All agree McCain’s concession speech was admirable, even honorable. Obama’s election fills many with hope. Hope for a better economy. Hope for an end to the insanity in Iraq. Hope for an America of which we can be justly proud: not an empire that lies and tortures, but a nation united in making the world a place of peace and opportunity and freedom and justice for all.

But I think: Do they really get it? Do these young adults, born in 1988 or 1990, really appreciate the magnitude of this event? I tell them: “I was born in 1955, three months before Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat. There’s no connection between the two events, except in my own mind. Just realize I was born into a country where segregation was legal, accepted and largely unquestioned. Those who began to challenge apartheid in the U.S.A. faced danger and death.” The kids look at me, curious and interested, but such a world is as foreign to them as descriptions of the Great Depression were to me when I was their age. “John Lewis wasn’t even recognized when he came on the screen last night,” I continue. “Who’s John Lewis?”

“I was born into a country where segregation was legal, accepted and largely unquestioned. Those who began to challenge apartheid in the U.S.A. faced danger and death.” The kids look at me, curious and interested, but such a world is as foreign to them as descriptions of the Great Depression were to me when I was their age.

1964 — I tell them the story of John Lewis. (See his autobiography “Walking With the Wind”.) He was a tiny little man, their age, when he joined the civil rights movement in 1960. By the time I was 9 years old, people like Lewis had radically changed the U.S.A. for the better. LBJ signed the Civil Rights Act in 1964, and the country changed. Lewis and other college “kids” like Diane Nash, James Bevel and Bernard Lafayette withstood hatred and beatings, even deaths of their friends, and quietly, nonviolently, courageously changed people’s hearts and minds. My world, our world, would never be the same. As Martin Luther King’s frontline foot soldiers in SNCC (the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee), those college-aged “kids” re-created America. Their achievements are chronicled in David Halberstam’s fascinating history, “The Children.”

Lewis has been a congressman for the past 22 years; I have been a Jesuit for over 30. The millenials’ world seems, culturally, light years from what mine was like when I was their age. In the 1960s and 1970s there was much tension between the races, and the O.J. verdict in 1995 revealed how much of a racial divide still existed in our country.

A Possible Future — Still, has something deep and seismic shifted with this election? Can we begin to “see” race and other social constructions in new and more edifying ways? I hope so. “Doonesbury” captures the mood and tone of this newer world. The day after the election, the strip shows soldiers in Iraq. A black soldier, Ray, shouts “Hoo-ah” when Obama’s elected. A white soldier chimes in. “What a great day. We did it!” Ray looks at him as the white soldier continues, “He’s half white you know.” Ray (Smiling? Chuckling? Tweaking or teasing his comrade?) replies, “You must be so proud.” The Jon Stewart-Colbertian ironic cool prevails. In another “Doonesbury” strip, Ray bristles at the assumption he must have voted for Obama. A white, female soldier calls him on the fact that he’d never vote for a “sailor.” (John McCain was a graduate of the Naval Academy.) Group identities and loyalties are ever-shifting social constructions for millenials, but Army still trumps Navy!

In a remarkably prescient final season of “The West Wing,” the tall, slim, cool Latino candidate (Jimmy Smits) ran against the older, white establishment candidate (Alan Alda), and the series depicted the Phillies as competing in the World Series. This October, my “Phightin’ Phils” won for only the second time in 126 years. I hope the day will come when we watch female and Latino and Asian candidates prevail in presidential races. Along with Colin Powell, we should recognize that a Muslim American child can dream that he or she will win the presidency. Which will come first, a second black president, a woman president, a Latino or Asian or Jewish president, or a third Phillies World Series championship? Prior to this year, I wouldn’t have held out much hope for any of the above. I have to confess, after last Tuesday’s election, anything seems possible now.

The Author : Richard G. Malloy, SJ
Richard G. Malloy, S.J., Ph.D., is Vice President for University Ministries, the University of Scranton, Scranton, PA, and author of A Faith That Frees (Orbis Books).
See more articles by (103).
Please note that the editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness.
  • Aileen ruane

    I join in congratulating our new President-elect. I think we can all recognize the historical significance of this event. However, I seriously doubt anyone would be congratulating Sarah Palin being the first female vice president or, say, if Mitt Romney had won the Republican nomination, the first Mormon president. This all comes down to ideology, so let’s not kid ourselves too much on the matter.

    Our church leadership in America tied its hands over this. Now the bishops are issuing a strongly worded document about President-elect Obama and his stances on life issues. They’re talking about excommunication, etc. I think, unfortunately, this is a matter of “too little, too late”. Obama’s viewpoints on the issue of abortion is well known. We as Christians have to decide whether we want a world without war and poverty, where people have access to health care, whether we want an end to abortion, or if we want the Federal government to do it for us. Because if we decide on the latter, then the hard truth lies with an old maxim: what the feds can give us, the feds can also take away.

  • Mike

    Dumb question but…

    What are WE doing to end abortion? How many unwed mothers did we take into our homes even though it stretched us financially? How many pregnancy crisis centers have we volunteered at–or do we even know where they are?

    We are not exonerated from playing a part in making abortion illegal simply by voting for someone who is what we might consider the lesser of two intrinsic evils. Rather, we need to make sure that politicians see us as people who are really committed to making abortion not merely illegal but a less attractive option–and most of us have done nothing in that regard.

  • Jim D

    It’s interesting how this Jesuit author writes in his November 5th comments about the hope inspired in many of his students by Obama’s election, but remains silent on hope for the unborn. Do his students not care about the unborn? If so, then say so. Does he think abortion is not important because of Obama’s other attrributes? If so, then say so. Even if he thinks Obama brings hope for peace, opportunity, freedom and justice for all (except the unborn), don’t ignore the abortion issue. Nathan’s post on November 14th reads “There is more to “life” than abortion” is interesting. Not so for those that are aborted. He also writes “Making it illegal won’t stop it from happening”. Should that be how we decide what is legal and illegal? If that is the test, what then would be made illegal? Should child abuse be legal because it’s my child and, anyway, making it illegal won’t prevent it from happening?

  • jill

    The man who will be President has charmed and mesmerized those who want Change….but at what cost? A society that overlooks the killing of the unborn has no future.

  • Nathan

    It really disappoints me to see that all people seem to care about is abortion. Not war, not the economy, not that a black man could be president when only 50 years ago people in white hoods were taking black men away and killing them. There is more to “life” than abortion. Making it illegal won’t stop it from happening. As a nation we need to go out there and prevent the ACTUAL causes of abortion. Let’s teach teens about birth control. Let’s face reality. A teenager NEVER listen to “just don’t do it.” Let’s pick our nation up from religious radicalism. Just remember my fellow Christians. The devil is everywhere, even in the church…..don’t let yourself be fooled.

  • Mike W

    I can’t disagree with this article more. Hope has been the buzzword for this campaign. There is no hope in a nation that sacrifices it’s unborn children.

    I give President Elect Obama the respect due to him as the office He has achieved demands it. What a great thing he has accomplished to be the first black man to come into the powerful position in the world.

    But that power is what scares me. The facts are simple.
    President Elect Obama has the most radical pro-abortion agenda in history. We must give him respect as president but as Catholics we should and we MUST challenge him in his desire to pass the Freedom of Choice Act.

  • GA Laura

    Craig, please take a look at catholics for obama.org I too had a hard time with his position on abortion vs my social values. I found the info on this website very enlightening.

  • Sue Peters

    Thank you Craig! We as Christians and Catholics have a responsibility to uphold life, first and foremost. We have serious work to do in our faith communities to help our brothers and sisters understand the importance of protecting the sanctity of life. I am saddened that there seems to be a disconnect in this generation, there is a lot of work to do. St. Paul, pray for us!

  • Craig Bradshaw

    Whilst this election screams out possibility, it does not outweigh or shadow Obama’s position on Abortion and the Right for Life. I think as Catholics we need to understand that. Where have our values gone?
    It is a great thing we elected an African American, but it is a sad day for Christians, especially with Obama announcing he plans to move forward with the FOCA.

    Be well,


  • Kazelzfu

    Hi webmaster!

powered by the Paulists