Someone told me to “just pray more.”
I was in my early 20s, dealing with what I now recognize as depression, and those three words were meant kindly. But they landed like a verdict — that my struggle was a spiritual failure, and enough faith would fix what medication and therapy were for. I tried. The prayers didn’t make the heaviness stop — the loss of interest in things I once loved, the low-grade dread that settled in each morning, the exhaustion that sleep didn’t fix.
What actually helped, more than I expected, was a combination of things: a therapist who didn’t ask me to choose between my faith and my treatment, an antidepressant that took the edge off the worst days, and discovering through spiritual direction and research that some of the greatest saints in Church history struggled with the same experiences — anxiety, darkness, intrusive thoughts — that I was navigating, and that none of them prayed their way out of it either.
RELATED: Approaching Mental Health Through a Catholic Lens With Deacon Ed Shoener
Catholic culture often presents the saints as people who conquered every human weakness through sheer holiness. The statues are serene. The holy cards show soft light. The unspoken implication is that if you’re anxious or depressed or taking mental health medication, you’re doing Catholicism wrong. For a lot of young Catholics — and for one in five Americans who live with a mental health condition — that implication does enormous damage.
The lives of the saints tell a different story.
St. Ignatius of Loyola
St. Ignatius of Loyola founded the Jesuits and wrote the Spiritual Exercises, one of the most influential works in Catholic history. During his conversion, he also suffered so severely from what we’d now call scrupulosity — a subtype of OCD characterized by obsessive religious guilt and intrusive thoughts — that he considered suicide. He described it in his own autobiography: the obsessive re-confessing, the certainty that he’d sinned even when he hadn’t, the inability to shake the feeling of spiritual contamination. He was tormented by doubts about whether he had confessed his sins adequately, and was so overwhelmed by intrusive thoughts that he considered taking his own life.
He didn’t pray his way to certainty. He learned to live with the uncertainty — partly through the guidance of a spiritual director who recognized his distress as something requiring pastoral care, not just more prayer, and partly through what we might now call behavioral practices: setting rules about when he was allowed to revisit confessions, limiting his re-examination of past sins, and finding structure when his mind wouldn’t settle. Inside that discipline, he built something lasting.
RELATED: Ryan Casey Waller on the Importance of Discussing Mental Health in the Church
St. Thérèse of Lisieux
St. Thérèse of Lisieux, known as ”The Little Flower,” is often presented as sweet and meek, adorned with roses. Less often mentioned: at 10, she suffered what looked like a nervous breakdown — thrashing in her bed, banging her head against the bedpost, and experiencing hallucinations. At 12, she developed scrupulosity that she never fully overcame. In her final two years, while she was dying of tuberculosis, she experienced almost total spiritual darkness — an inability to feel God’s presence that mirrors clinical depression closely enough that scholars have debated the diagnosis for decades. She didn’t experience holiness instead of suffering. She experienced it through it.
St. John of the Cross
The phrase “Dark Night of the Soul” has become so common people forget St. John of the Cross literally wrote the book on it. The 16th-century Spanish Carmelite describes spiritual desolation — the felt absence of God, the inability to pray, the loss of meaning and consolation. As Psychiatric Times has noted, the dark night itself is not a disease, but part of the price we pay for being vulnerable human beings. St. John of the Cross understood something it took Western psychology centuries to catch up to: that spiritual suffering and clinical depression can coexist. They’re not the same thing, but they’re not mutually exclusive either. Both are real. Both deserve care.
Here’s what I wish someone had told me when I was struggling: Getting help isn’t a sign that your faith is weak. It’s a sign that you’re paying attention to the life God gave you. The saints didn’t bypass human suffering through holiness — they found their spiritual directors, their confessors, their communities, their ways of holding on. Finding a therapist, or a support group, or the right medication follows the same instinct. It’s not a replacement for faith. And for a lot of people, it’s what helps make faith possible.
The Church is slowly catching up. In 2023, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops launched a National Catholic Mental Health Campaign. That’s significant — but it’s catching up to something the saints already knew.
St. Ignatius had intrusive thoughts. St. Thérèse had what looked like a breakdown. St. John of the Cross wrote his greatest work out of a darkness he couldn’t pray his way out of.
We’re in good company.
