A listener named Becca asks Father Dave about how to approach an interfaith interaction. Becca says, “[Sometimes] Mormons come to my property; I ask them to leave and they get a bit bothered. They ask if they can pray with me, and I say ‘No, thank you.’ Am I wrong for saying no?”
Father Dave first notes that we don’t need to engage with a person trying to convert us to a different faith. “It’s certainly your right, with courtesy or hospitality, to tell someone that you don’t want to hear what they have to say. There’s nothing wrong with that,” he says.
LISTEN: Why Can’t Christians of Other Denominations Receive the Eucharist in a Catholic Church?
“There’s plenty of Christians of various denominations, and even Catholics, that might practice some door-to-door or public evangelization and might ask to pray with people, and if somebody says no, then we [should] respect that,” Father Dave continues. “If you were at somebody’s house who is Jewish or Muslim, and they said, ‘Would you like to pray with us?’ If you were to say, ‘No, thank you, that’s not my religious belief.’ I would hope they would respect that, and you also should not feel bad for saying that.”
Father Dave notes that in visiting other churches, synagogues, or mosques, there are different standards for visitors. “If we’re going by the somewhat-accepted protocols of interfaith prayer, we always err on the side of the other person who is not of that faith to choose their comfort level. If you want to stand up when we stand up and say amen when we say amen, that’s fine with us, but we believe words matter,” he says. “To say amen, we believe [that you] truly assent to what’s just been said. It’s like ratifying something; it would be like putting your signature on a contract where you disagree with several paragraphs in it.”
LISTEN: Can Catholics Sing Contemporary Christian Music During Mass?
“I think Christ would have us say no to someone else in the most charitable and hospitable way that we could, but Christ doesn’t prevent us from saying no to people,” Father Dave continues. “We can take the higher road, even if they’re bothered, or exerting pressure, and courteously say ‘No thanks…I’m very comfortable in my faith and my belief. I appreciate what you’re doing, but I don’t feel comfortable entering into prayer with you.’”
Father Dave adds, “It’s not the Catholic Church’s official position to say that we would never pray with people of other faiths. Certainly, popes have been part of interfaith prayer services, so it’s not that we as a rule put up this wall and say, ‘We will not pray with you.’ What I’m saying to you, Becca, is if you don’t feel comfortable for whatever reason, there’s nothing wrong with saying ‘No, I choose not to pray with you, but may God be with you.’”