Should Priests Correct People Who Kneel While Receiving the Eucharist?

Share

A listener named John asks Father Dave about correct postures when receiving the Eucharist. “I’ve seen an increase of people kneeling to receive communion. I’ve heard Father Dave comment on this before, but I’m wondering if he can address this.” John begins. “Every week, our priest calls out people for leaving after communion [before Mass ends]. Why not correct those who kneel to receive when that’s not an option given to us by the Church, when not in a traditional Latin Mass setting?”

Father Dave begins, “There are segments of the Church in union with the Holy Father that have certain permission to celebrate rituals in a different way, but ideally, we don’t mix and match. So yes, there are people that a bishop has given permission in a diocese that this church may celebrate what some people call the traditional Latin Mass, TLM, or the extraordinary form of the Roman Rite, but the idea is, it’s a package deal.”

RELATED: Shouldn’t We Receive Communion on Our Knees?

He explains that in the Ordinary Form of the Mass, the General Instruction of the Roman Missal instructs us to stand while receiving the Eucharist. “Everything we do, standing and kneeling, and the responses that we have — we individually don’t make any of that up. If one were to say, ‘I love Saint Paul so much, and want to show reverence to Saint Paul’s writings in the Scriptures. So instead of standing during the Gospel, I’m going to stand during the second reading.’ Now you may say, ‘Of course, no one’s going to do that,’ but it’s just as out of the ordinary and against the norm, as are  is some other choices that people do make, that are their own choices that are not the ritual that we’re doing.”

“When we make a change like what happened at the Second Vatican Council, it was the first time in 500 years a change to some of the particulars of the ritual of the Mass had been made,” Father Dave continues. “This first change was made after three years of intensive prayer, gathering, and discussion for bishops from all over the world who came to the Vatican during the mid 1960s. They consulted experts and theologians, and prayed intensely under the guidance of the Holy Spirit to make a decision to change a particular posture or ritual at Mass. It’s not something that me as a communicant, meaning someone going up for communion, can decide to do on my own.”

Father Dave notes, “Soon after the Roman Missal was revised in 2011, there was an official inquiry put to the office at the Vatican that makes these big decisions about Liturgy and how we celebrate around the world. The question asked was what John has asked, which is, if someone is choosing to do some sort of posture or ritual that is not called for by the rite and is different from what everybody else is doing, should they be refused or instructed right in that moment that that is wrong? The official word from the Vatican was that, because it is such a sacramental moment and a very powerful spiritual moment for many people, that’s not the moment to do that. We’ve been instructed that we should not refuse communion for this.”

WATCH: Sacraments 101 (How We Receive)

The Vatican instead instructs priests to find a different pastoral way to correct people. “What we’re asked to do by the Church is to educate people as to why the Church has chosen these particular rituals,” Father Dave explains, offering perhaps to pull those people aside after Mass or write a column in the bulletin.

In regards to John’s example however, Father Dave feels that it is more delicate to instruct on this teaching compared to why we don’t leave Mass early. “It’s a little harder to castigate people for being more pious or reverent than we’re asked to be. However, I would still stand on the fact that Mass is a we thing, and we’re all doing this together. It’s not looking around the room and seeing who is more pious and more devout by seeing who is standing up or kneeling down. It is a unified ritual, and that’s why all these things are codified, and that’s why we do them.”

Father Dave, Brett, and Krista select portions of the radio show each week to be featured podcasts. Check out the radio blog for daily show notes for our updates about guests, links, and more!

Stay Connected with Busted Halo

Join our community and receive the latest updates, reflections, and resources directly to your inbox.

Voices from the Back Pew

Honest stories from Catholics who question, struggle, or wrestle with faith and Church — reminding us all that no one sits alone in the pews.

More from Team Busted Halo

More from Podcasts

Like what you see? 

Sign up for the Busted Halo weekly newsletter for more faith shared joyfully (straight to your inbox)

Subscribe

* indicates required

NOTE: We're only sending email messages to people who CHECK THIS BOX. So, if you want to hear from us, go ahead and check the box! Busted Halo will use the information you provide on this form to provide you with content and fundraising updates. Please confirm that you would like to hear from us via email:

You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at info@bustedhalo.com. We will treat your information with respect. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices.