Busted Halo
feature: entertainment & lifestyle
May 17th, 2011

In the Bones

Why this show's exploration of faith vs. reason is so appealing



A priest is found murdered in an old church cemetery. Special Agent Seeley Booth and Dr. Temperance Brennan investigate the crime scene and question another priest. Brennan takes cheap shot. “Father, I believe this has been consecrated a crime scene”. Booth, a cradle Catholic, pleads with her to be respectful. Why should I, she responds, because he believes “a plot of earth has supernatural properties because [he] waved a wand over it [and] used magic water?” Unable to reason with her, Booth complains that she refers to God as his “invisible friend,” to which Brennan, an atheist, responds, “Yes, you’re talking to someone who isn’t there.”

Exploring the tension between faith and reason is just one of the many interesting elements of the television series, Bones, currently in its sixth season on Fox, and one that keeps me watching each week. The aforementioned partners do more than just examine crimes, they inform each other and the viewers about the dichotomous worlds from which they approach life.

Booth, a former altar boy, attends Mass every Sunday but doesn’t put much thought into understanding his faith on a deeper level. He doesn’t need to be convinced to believe; he just does. Dr. Brennan, is the polar opposite. Being a forensic anthropologist, she believes that all things can be proven logically thus negating any need for a god.

These partners hash out the faith vs. logic debate as they work together solving murders for the FBI. On the outside, they appear to have nothing more in common than solving the crimes. Witnessing their weekly interactions, viewers find that what really holds them together is their morality. They both abide by strict moral codes, albeit through different means. Brennan through natural law and reason, and Booth through his Catholic faith and experience. As the series explores their relationship, these partners illustrate how faith and reason benefit each other, and how either one by itself is lacking.

For the Bible tells me so

Because Brennan has pushed him to explain himself, Booth is actually becoming a better Catholic. He has to figure out his beliefs and say more than just, “That’s what the Bible says.”

One episode, “Death in the Saddle,” deals with a group of people with a certain fetish (one I wish I hadn’t learned existed.) Throughout the episode Booth is grossed out and repeatedly states how freakish the subjects of the investigation are. Brennan defends them, saying people like different things and are entitled to their opinions:

Brennan: Why are you being so judgmental?
Booth: When you turn someone into an object of sexual pleasure, it’s wrong.
Brennan: How do you know?
Booth: It says so in the Bible.
Brennan: Does not.
Booth: Then it got left out by mistake.

I can tell by watching this interaction that Booth was probably taught this back in catechism class. Turning people into an object for pleasure is wrong — I’ve repeated that to my own students a million times. Even though he is saying the right thing, he can’t explain why it’s right because he’s never thought about it. After thinking about it further he has a better defense by the end of the episode:

Booth: Making love — making love — that’s when two people become one.
Brennan: It is scientifically impossible for two objects to occupy the same space.
Booth: Yeah but what’s important is we try and when we do it right, we get close.
Brennan: To what? Breaking the laws of physics?
Booth: Yeah, Bones — a miracle. All those people with their role-playing and their fetishes and their little sex games — it’s crappy sex. At least compared to the real thing.

Because Brennan has pushed him to explain himself, Booth is actually becoming a better Catholic. He has to figure out his beliefs and say more than just, “That’s what the Bible says.” And Brennan grows from these interactions too. At the end of this conversation, she agrees with him. In her head she might be able to justify what these people are doing, but Booth makes her realize he has a point.

While Booth believes what the Church tells him to believe, if he disagrees with something then he just pretends it doesn’t exist. Brennan, on the other hand, always deals with the facts. In one episode Booth and Brennan talk about the story of Abraham being willing to sacrifice his Isaac:

Booth: Well, that’s the one Bible story that I just don’t like. I mean, God commands Abraham to kill his own son and he does.
Brennan: Abraham does not kill Isaac.
Booth: But old Abe, he had the intention.
Brennan: I thought what he had was faith.
Booth: Look, I have faith. But if God himself came down, pointed at Parker and said I want you to, you know, that ain’t gonna happen…
Brennan: Ok, then the lesson I would learn from this myth… That when it comes to your children your love has to be absolute. The messenger represents goodness, what you know to be right, ergo you have to remain open to what you know is true.

It’s ironic that, in this case, the tables are turned. Booth, always the reactive sort, doesn’t like the story so he pushes it out of his mind. He doesn’t try to figure out what lesson God is trying to teach, he reads it and rejects it. Brennan stops to think about it even though she’s not a believer. Though she doesn’t necessarily conclude the correct moral of the story — thus showing she is in need of the wisdom of the Church — Brennan is helping her partner’s faith grow.

Faith in something

In Booth, Brennan finds a person who loves her despite her quirks, who she can’t push far enough away to make him leave and who is fiercely loyal to her. This is a God-like love. And she finds herself completely trusting him despite logic telling her she should never trust anyone.

One of the most poignant conversations the two have about God happens in an episode in which Brennan is buried alive and eventually rescued. At the end of the episode, Booth and Brennan are sitting in a church, Booth just finishing praying,

Brennan: If there was a God, which there isn’t, and if I was someone who believed he had a plan, then I’d be tempted to think that he wanted me to go through something like what I went through because it would make me more open to the concept.
Booth: Which obviously it hasn’t.
Brennan: I’m okay with you thanking God for saving me and Hodgins.
Booth: That’s not what I’m thanking God for. I thanked him for saving all of us. It was all of us. Every single one. You take one of us away and you and Hodgins are in that hole forever. And I’m thankful for that.
Brennan: I knew you wouldn’t give up.

While Brennan makes it very clear that she has not developed any faith in God, she has developed a very strong faith in Booth. This is a huge step for a woman who keeps her distance from all people and walls herself in with facts and objectivity. Booth shows Brennan a love that she has never experienced before. Her parents abandoned her in her teens; her brother ran out on her; she bounced around the foster system. This is why she retreated into science. But in Booth, she finds a person who loves her despite her quirks, who she can’t push far enough away to make him leave and who is fiercely loyal to her. This is a God-like love. And she finds herself completely trusting him despite logic telling her she should never trust anyone. It is reasonable to assume that because she has learned to let down her guard a bit and put her trust and faith in a person — Booth — then she could one day be open to putting her trust and faith in God.

The series’ writers are amazing at crafting faith themes and a tension that keeps viewers riveted week to week. The main characters’ relationship with each other can be so antagonistic and yet so full of love at the same time, and each week they grow and develop in a way that is authentic and endearing. Don’t even get me started on the will-they-or-won’t-they sexual tension that exists between the pair; that’s a whole other reason that keeps me watching.

When it comes down to it, these partners need each other. They demonstrate how faith needs reason and reason needs faith. They each have both and they depend on one another to bring it out. Combine these twos’ powers and they would make one heck of a Catholic superhero or, at the very least, one sexy theologian.

The Bones sixth season finale airs this Thursday, May 19, 2011 on Fox at 9 p.m. ET/PT.

The Author : Vanessa Gonzalez Kraft
Vanessa, a Notre Dame grad, loves the Catholic Worker Movement, Catholic education, and overbearing Mexican mothers, which she may or may not be. She lives in Austin with her husband and five daughters and is a freelance writer. You can find Vanessa at v.kraft.im or follow Vanessa on Twitter @laluped.
See more articles by (104).
Please note that the editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness.
  • Raouf

    Despite what the pdcruoer stated in the interview, they would have never done the Brennan pregnancy as a story line this season, going into next season. Emily’s real-life pregnancy is the best thing that could have happened to the Bones series. Season 6 was one of the best to date and reminded me of the first three seasons.

  • DaveMD

    Symbolically, they should get together. Faith (Bones) and reason (Brennan) are made for each other. Alone they are not enough, nor are they what God intended for us. Reason (intellect) helps us to know (love) God better by allowing us to better discover and appreciate all of His creation – including ourselves. It also utilizes the gifts He gave us to better ourselves in this world so that we may be useful to Him in bringing about His kingdom on earth.

  • sue

    Joe–of course I am voting for them to get together but still have their views, that tension makes their discussions interesting. However, I don’t know about how to do the marriage thing with regard to the whole show. Angie and Hodgins just got married, and just had their baby. Seems like another storyline like that is not what the show needs…but it would be interesting to see Bones as a mom and how she’d deal with that whole thing, being the scientist who never gets close to people.

  • Julie Hagan Bloch

    I’m voting for Brennan and Booth to get together. I’d be disappointed if she suddenly drops her logical outlook in favor of any particular cultural tradition.

  • joe

    question to hard-core Bones fans out there… What’s more likely to happen, that Brennan will one day believe in God or that she and Booth will get together?

  • Christina

    I really appreciated this posting because Bones is my favoriate television show. As someone who was raised Catholic, I like seeing a character on TV who makes attempts to share his faith with others, even if he is still trying to grow in his understanding of Catholicism. I can also relate to Brennan because I’m a logical person. The difference is that my logical thinking process helps lead me to knowing God exists and maybe eventually this will occur for Brennan’s character. I think there is the potential for many thought provoking discussions on faith between Booth and Brennan as the new season begins in the fall and their relationship continues to change. Thanks for an interesting look at some of Booth and Bone’s discussions on faith!

  • Julie Hagan Bloch

    I also am a fan of this program. Personally, I am on the side of Brennan’s logic. She makes an excellent point about the whole Abraham myth: if someone tells you to do something that feels wrong, just don’t do it. How many people have, against their better judgement, trusted those in authority with disastrous results?
    Her faith in Booth is based on her experience, not unverifiable tales told by and about other people.

  • JoeMart

    Great article. I haven’t seen Bones in a long time, but somehow I knew every episode you were referencing. I used to watch it in high school and I could’t remember why I liked it so much. I’m gonna have to check it out again.

  • AnitaH

    I love this show too and this is one of the reasons why. A cradle Catholic myself, I love that through his relationship with Brennan Booth is pushed beyond the rhetoric which we were taught in CCD and to really understand why we believe what we believe.

  • SrGayle

    I am also a big fan of Bones. Booth and Brennan both respect each other, which is very important with 2 people with very different belief systems. It is very well-written dialogue. Also, Brennan seems to be opening up more emotionally to Booth.:-) Thanks for the article.

powered by the Paulists