GOOD Christmas Music!

I realize that in my last post, I might have come off as kind of a grump… exams and papers will do that to you.  Not that I take back anything that I said regarding the importance of Advent or the true awfulness of the song “Last Christmas,” but when I hit the “Send” button on my last paper of the semester this past Saturday, the holidays began for me!

Still, after my last post I do feel the need to prove that I am not a total Mr. Potter.  In fact, it’s because I like Christmas music so much that I can’t stand when it is co-opted in order to give second-rate musical artists a shot towards achieving some “American Idol” style mediocrity.  So with that in mind, I would like to offer what I will be playing on my iPhone this holiday season!

Barenaked Ladies and Sarah McLachlan: God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
Made me proud to be Gen X!  Modern, fun, and reverent… not an easy hat trick but the Canadian artists pull it off.

Jack Skelington: What’s This?

“This children are throwing snowballs… instead of throwing heads!  There’s frost in every window, and absolutely no one’s dead!”  This song from The Nightmare Before Christmas has humor with a very classic feel.

Pink Martini: Do You Hear What I Hear?

I actually downloaded this song while writing my last post on Advent… and this version is so good it’s been on repeat on my iPod.

Los Straighjakcets: Deck The Halls

Got it off Amazon’s free MP3 giveaway on Black Friday.  A fun twist!

Harry Connick, Jr.: Must Have Been Old Santa

Too many artists simply mail in Christmas albums as a way to capitalize on their lack of ability to create hits; it’s a sad attempt to be relevant.  But every time Harry Connick Jr. releases a Christmas album, I buy it; if the promise of God’s eternal salvation does not make you glad for the birth of Christ, maybe this album will tip the scales for you!

Ray Conniff: Medley: Let It Snow! / Count Your Blessings / We Wish You A Merry Christmas

My parents used to play this as we decorated the house.  It’s cheesy, but cheesy is not always bad… as my friends will tell you!

Darlene Love: Marshmallow World

On November 22, 1963, perhaps the greatest Christmas album of all time was released; it was also the same day that John F. Kennedy died.  Consequently, the genius of A Christmas Gift for You from Phil Spector was initially missed.  Thankfully, in subsequent years the album was rediscovered and the music has been a holiday mainstay ever since.
Every, every, every song on this album is fantastic.  I picked this one so other songs would have a chance to make the list.  Don’t just take my word for it; Rolling Stone ranked it as 142 on the list of the 500 greatest albums of all time.

The Pretenders: 2000 Miles
I found myself missing someone in the middle of Mass in the not too distant past.  And as I thought of this person, I realized that 2,000 miles could mean a lot more than physical distance,

Dave Matthews: A Christmas Song

One of the few Christmas songs that actually covers the life of Jesus after he was born.  Not bad for a self-confessed agnostic.

Bruce Springsteen: Santa Claus is Coming To Town

As a native of the great state of New Jersey, the holidays do not offically begin until Bruce declares that the “Wind is whipping down the boardwalk!”

Andy Gullahorn: I Will Find A Way
A song that is either about God reaching out to us… or the journey all of must make at least once in our life to those who appear to be unreachable.  A really nice meditation about what Christmas should be once all of the exterior traditions and trappings have cleared.

Nat King Cole: THE Christmas Song

I’ve tried to include songs that do not get overplayed.  This song still qualifies because it can never be overplayed.

Brian Seltzer Orchestra: Angels We Have Heard On High

Simultaneously fun, thrilling, and even a little sacred… but not too sacred for this Stray Cat. Bu this song if you do not own it.

Bing Crosby and Rosemary Clooney: Count Your Blessings

From the movie White Christmas… which is the only reason why it’s included in the Christma-only radio station play list.  Yet it’s not a bad standby… and it has a good message.

They Might Be Giants: New York City

I have a pet peeve about certain songs that purport themselves to be Christmas songs.  For example, just because “Favorite Things” from the Sound of Music makes a tangential reference to snowflakes and sleigh bells and all of a sudden, it slipped into the Christmas canon like some
However, the song “New York City” is where I will admit to being a hypocrite.  But this song FEELS like New York City at Christmas time, just as much as Silver Bells does.  Because everyone IS your friend in New York City!  Especially during the holidays!  Just don’t make eye contact…

Rent Soundtrack: Seasons of Love

Again, this is not necessarily a Christmas song, but it is a great New Year’s song… but since it asks us to mark 525,600 minutes with the moments we love, it’s not that off of the mark.  Plus it IS a great New Year’s song.

Squirrell Nut Zippers: Christmas in Carolina

I assume that Christmas in Carolina is great, but I cannot say for myself.  I more included this because one of my sister’s is going to be away for Christmas for the first time visiting her husband’s family.  It’s still a good song even if your sister is not spending the holiday in North Carolina.

That’s my list.  It is not all encompassing, but I think I have some good mix of the secular and religious in here.  Feel free to comment on your favorites… and Merry Christmas!

Since 2009, Tom Gibbons, CSP, has shared insights on faith, pop culture, and seminary life in the Kicking and Screaming blog here at Busted Halo. On May 19, 2012, Tom was ordained a Paulist priest at St. Paul the Apostle Church in New York City. He will begin serving St. Peter's Catholic Church in Toronto, Canada beginning in July 2012.